Indians assume the festive season as a good time to invest in gold. However, it is important to recognise that India’s connection to gold during festivals is cultural rather than financial. Occasions like Dhanteras, Sankranti, Ugadi and Akshaya Tritiya draw Indians to gold. Gold ETFs allow investors to honour these cultural expectations without worrying about the high ticket size required to purchase gold jewellery, or concerns over storage and purity.
Going by historical trends, demand often pushes prices up during festival time. As on November 17, the price of gold in India was around Rs1.25 lakh per 10 grams (22 carat). The sensible approach is to treat gold as a long-term portfolio allocation rather than a seasonal bet, investing steadily instead of chasing the calendar.
Some experts argue that the festive season is not an ideal time to invest in Gold ETFs, as global forces usually dictate prices. “US yields, the dollar and Fed policy moves overwhelm local seasonality. This year, prices fell from the January peak even while the festive window ran, and buyers stepped into the dip through ETFs and physical gold. The calendar itself creates no edge. Stay inside your planned allocation because, in the long run, timing the market does not work—time in the market does. Season does not matter; your overall asset allocation and goals do,” said Anshi Shrivastava, head of personal finance training at 1 Finance.
Her advice for investors is to skip the seasonal narrative. “Volatility from US policy and global factors is normal for this asset. Where FoFs (Fund of Funds) are closed for new money, direct ETFs stay open if you have a demat account. Gold ETFs fit a planned allocation and do not replace equities or debt,” she said.
Personal finance experts also emphasise that investors should make decisions based on asset allocation, portfolio requirements and long-term financial goals.
“Gold has witnessed a strong rally in recent years. Our analysis of its long-term performance indicates that gold has a less than 50 per cent probability of generating a 10 per cent CAGR over a 10-year timeline, and it has also been inconsistent in delivering stable returns across investment cycles. Therefore, there is a possibility of mean reversion, where returns could moderate or prices could correct after an extended rally. Chasing gold’s recent performance at elevated price levels may not be an ideal investment strategy,” said Protima Dhawan, director and unit head, Anand Rathi Wealth.
Because gold is influenced by multiple global macroeconomic factors, elevated interest rates create headwinds. Gold is a non-interest-bearing asset, and higher interest rates increase the opportunity cost of holding it, putting downward pressure on prices. Moreover, following the recent rally, there is a risk of profit booking and mean reversion. Investors should avoid treating gold as a guaranteed source of returns and should not increase their allocations simply because of the festive season.
Indian investors inherit volatility they cannot control because gold’s price is set globally. “The metal moves sharply on US Fed rate expectations. Typically, easier policy tends to lift it, since non-yielding gold competes with bond yields. The rupee adds a second layer. For investors, the challenge is psychological as much as financial: resisting the urge to buy at peaks and panic-sell at troughs. Often, discipline—not timing—protects returns,” said Prof Ram Kumar Kakani, vice chancellor of RV University, Bengaluru.
Recently, 17 fund houses blocked fresh lump sums and new SIPs into Gold ETF FoFs starting in mid-October, though existing SIPs and redemptions continue uninterrupted. Direct Gold ETFs also remain fully open. The move followed a regulatory nudge to slow excess gold imports and ease pressure on the rupee during peak festive demand. While this hurts convenience for investors who prefer FoFs because they do not require a demat account, the overall impact remains limited.
Gold ETFs offer several advantages in terms of affordability, convenience, transparency and cost efficiency compared with physical or digital gold. However, flexibility and ease of investing do not make gold an efficient wealth-creation tool. “Our historical analysis of rolling returns shows gold has had a less than 50 per cent probability of generating a 10 per cent CAGR across 3-, 5-, and 10-year investment horizons, whereas the Nifty has a 68.99 per cent probability of delivering a 10 per cent CAGR over a 10-year period. Therefore, Gold ETFs can be an efficient and convenient way to gain exposure to gold, but not to build long-term wealth,” said Dhawan.
The structural trend is firming up. Indian Gold ETF holdings have nearly doubled since 2021, and the regulator is weighing allowing pension funds greater Gold ETF exposure. Their appeal lies in transparent exchange pricing, zero purity or storage worries, and, most importantly, the ability to buy in small amounts. “The Hitopadesha counsel that wealth be guarded wisely, not merely hoarded, captures the spirit of ETFs—turning a traditional store of value into a liquid holding,” said Kakani. “For the small investor, they bridge our love for gold.”