Though India has made it into the semi-finals after a victory against Bangladesh, the match may end up costing the boys in blue their captain.
In the 11th over, Mohammad Shami hit Soumya Sarkar on the pads, prompting Shami to appeal for a leg-before-wicket (LBW). On-field umpire, Marais Erasmus, turned the appeal down, which led Kohli to ask for a review on the big screen. The third umpire, Aleem Dar, decided that the ball appeared to strike bat and pad at the same time, and maintained Erasmus’s decision. The Third Umpire did not proceed to the ball tracking screen.
There was no conclusive evidence of bat first.. So benefit of doubt to batsman, not out, fine.. But third umpire should have watched ball tracker and as it was umpire's call, review should have been retained.!! #INDvBAN #IndiaVsBangladesh
— Vikram Joshi 🇮🇳 (@vikramajoshi) July 2, 2019
With this costing India a review, Kohli got into an argument with Erasmus. M.S. Dhoni was not present at the time. Kohli may have been a tad too animated following the review loss for India.
Kohli marches over to the umpires after that DRS decision. Gesticulates, then hands on hips. Not a good look.
— Lawrence Booth (@the_topspin) July 2, 2019
Indians fans were also outraged, feeling like the Decision Review System (DRS) had feel unfavourable to India on multiple occassions.
Unfortunately #TeamIndia ends up on the wrong side of the #DRS, most of the times. #BANvIND #CWC19
— Arsham Khawaja (@arsham92) July 2, 2019
The argument could cost Kohli dearly. The skipper had already been fined for arguing with an umpire during the match against Afghanistan. Then, he was fined 25 per cent of his match fee and received one demerit point for being in breach of section 2.1 of the ICC Code of Conduct, which has to do with “Excessive appealing during an International Match”. Aleem Dar was the on-field umpire at that match.
Kohli already had a demerit point from a 2018 test match played against South Africa in Pretoria, where he was also found in violation of section 2.1.1, for ‘conduct contrary to the spirit of the game.’ With two demerit points in hand, Kohli is two points short of a two-ODI-match ban.
If Kohli is found in violation of 2.1 again, he may be given another demerit point — or two. Excessive appealing is a Level 1 offence, which can carry a maximum of two demerit points. However, repetition of a level 1 offence within a period of 12 months makes for a level 2 offence, where the penalties include being fined 50-100 per cent of match fee and/or receiving 3-4 demerit points. Demerit points remain for a period of 24 months.
The official ICC website says:
“When a player reaches four or more demerit points within a 24-month period, they are converted into suspension points and a player is banned...Two suspension points equate to a ban from one Test or two ODIs or two T20Is, whatever comes first for the player.”
ALSO READ
- 'King' beats Kings: Virat Kohli's exceptional 50 carries RCB to 4-wicket victory over PBKS
- IPL records: Highest batting partnerships by wicket; RCB's Virat Kohli and AB de Villiers to MI's Ambati Rayudu and Kieron Pollard
- IPL 2024: Teams reveal jerseys for new season; Rajasthan Royals 'All Pink' to RCB's 'Green', see pics here
Whether Kohli’s conduct will count as ‘excessive appealing’ will depend on the umpires. The ICC Code of Conduct mentions four situations that can come under the tag of an excessive appeal:
“1: Repeated appealing of the same decision.
2: Repeated appealing of different decisions when the bowler/fielder knows the
batter is not out with the intention of placing the Umpire under pressure.
3: Charging or advancing towards the Umpire in an aggressive manner when appealing.
4: Celebrating a dismissal without appealing to the Umpire when a decision is required.”
The rules add that these are not intended to “prevent loud or enthusiastic appealing”.
Kohli is the highest ranked test and ODI batsman in the world. India will next play Sri Lanka at Leeds on July 6.