Washington, DC
A MAJOR CHANGE in the US immigration policy is unlikely anytime soon, notwithstanding the midterm results. In fact, two particularly relevant immigration policies affecting Indian migrant workers predate Trump.
The first concerns what happens when an H-1B worker loses a job. An American worker who is laid off can look for another job without worrying about losing the right to remain in the country. H-1B workers, however, normally have to find another job within 60 days. If they cannot, they risk losing their lawful status and must leave the country.
The second important factor concerns the H-1B lottery. There are only 66,000 H-1B visas available each year under regular allocation. There was a time when half a million people would apply for these limited slots. Employers would submit applications in April for the following fiscal year, which begins in October, and applicants would be selected through a lottery. Some IT companies submitted four or five applications for the same individual, thereby increasing that person’s chances of selection. The Biden administration stopped this practice by introducing a system that identifies individual applicants through their passport numbers.
The Trump administration continued this policy and introduced another change, making the H-1B lottery wage-weighted. Under this system, workers offered higher wages have a better chance of being selected than those offered lower wages. If you are a highly skilled professional sought after by a company such as Microsoft, your chances are better.
Meanwhile, the green-card backlog issue goes back to the immigration system established in 1990. To move from an H-1B visa to a green card through employment-based immigration, a worker must be sponsored by an employer, who must establish that no comparable American worker is available for the job.
There are only 1,40,000 employment-based green cards available annually for the entire world. This figure also includes the spouses and children of principal applicants. Roughly half that number is available for the workers themselves. There is also a country quota: no country can receive more than 7 per cent of the available allocation. This formula disproportionately affects nationals of India and China. Even if you have a PhD from one of the best American universities and are sponsored by a major company such as Microsoft, you still have to stand in the queue. For Indians, the waiting period is now estimated to be around 13 years. There are close to half a million Indians waiting, and some estimates suggest that clearing the queue could take two lifetimes.
Now imagine what happens when the industry undergoes a major economic disruption and the employer who sponsored you must lay you off. You have spent years waiting in the green-card queue, but suddenly you have lost your job and must find another employer within 60 days. You can see how these two policies interact to create enormous anxiety for immigrants.
Another concern is the Trump administration's attempt to curtail opportunities for practical training. Foreign students who complete a degree in the US are generally given a period of practical training to find employment in their field of study. Optional Practical Training has been an important bridge between being a student and entering the H-1B system. Though the proposal has yet to be finalised, the administration has proposed a rule requiring universities to remit a $70,000 fee for initial OPT. Such a measure would have a huge impact, even if universities could distribute the fees among employers and foreign students.
Indian families now have to undertake a careful cost-benefit analysis, particularly those financing their children’s education entirely on their own. If you mortgage your savings to send your child to the US for a master’s degree in an IT field, assuming they will soon find a lucrative job in Silicon Valley, that calculation needs to be reassessed.
On the other hand, if a student receives a scholarship or is exceptionally talented, the calculation is different. Extraordinary and highly qualified students will probably continue to find opportunities. Their pathway from OPT to H-1B is wider than that of an average student entering the IT workforce.
The Trump administration has been particularly sceptical of cultural and academic exchange programmes, especially those involving Chinese researchers, a position evident even during Trump’s first presidency. It believes there are competitive and security risks involved.
The reality is that the motivation of this administration is not necessarily based on merit. That is true not just of immigration policy but also of its economic, foreign and defence policies. Trump’s second presidency is very different from his first. During his first term, there were well-regarded professionals running various government agencies. That is largely missing now.
While opportunities in the US have diminished or have become more segmented, some advanced economies, particularly in Europe and Australia, are trying to attract professionals who might otherwise have gone to the US. The UK is somewhat less prominent in this regard. These countries have opened up opportunities, but I do not know how long it will take for the market to find its level. The IT industry is unusually global, and I cannot imagine that what is happening in Silicon Valley is not also happening in Berlin or Canberra.
I would place more hope in developments within the US Congress following the midterm results than in opportunities opening up elsewhere. US companies have considerable influence in US politics, and if employers dependent on IT workers find a more receptive audience in Congress, there could be an opening for change.
Chishti is senior fellow, Migration Policy Institute, Washington, DC.
—As told to Namrata Biji Ahuja