Chennai, Nov 17 (PTI) CPI (M) MP Su Venkatesan on Tuesday refuted Justice G R Swaminathan's criticism targeting his lifestyle, asserting that he does not own a car to this day and termed the judge's comments as "cheap personal attack."
The judge had also recalled a train journey, saying while he travelled sleeper class, the Left MP picked first class.
Reacting to the sharp observations made during an open court hearing, Venkatesan said in a statement on his official social media handle that his train journey was strictly within the official travel entitlements granted to a Member of Parliament.
"Criticism made without verifying facts, based solely on superficial observations, reveal bias and descend into personal attacks," Venkatesan stated.
Challenging the notion that a leader's integrity is tied to their travel class, he added, "a person's argument does not become wrong just because they travel in first class, nor does someone become right merely by traveling in sleeper class. An intelligent society will weigh such comparisons wisely."
Affirming his ideological roots, he said that he took immense pride in being a communist. "Communism taught me to question. When that question provokes a response, the validity of the question is affirmed. No slander can destroy this lesson."
He noted that while left leaders are frequently questioned over the clothes they wear or the vehicles they use, they remain accountable when such questions are raised in the spirit of the party's core principles of "purity and simplicity."
"We were raised by a proud party that instilled this responsibility in us," the Madurai Lok Sabha MP said.
Venkatesan took on his critics by questioning their underlying motives and political stance, and declared that he and his party would continue to stand proudly on the side of rationalism in the ideological battle against superstition and dogma, adding that the struggle neither began with them nor would end with them.
"I have been criticised for the car I arrived in at the railway station. When such criticism is made without checking the facts, based on superficial observation, it reveals bias and becomes a personal attack. It is a cheap personal attack. It is not my car; I have never owned a car to this day," he said, adding that a person's standing in society is shaped by his views and actions.
On Monday, taking strong exception to Venkatesan's recent comments on judicial duties, Madras High Court judge Justice Swaminathan had remarked that the Communist leader was trying to lecture him on his responsibilities and said that the Lok Sabha MP travelled in a Benz car.
During a contempt hearing regarding the library book procurement scam, Justice Swaminathan clarified that his earlier remark about placing spiritual books in the library was strictly meant as a joke. Turning his attention to Venkatesan's earlier criticism, he recounted a chance encounter with the MP at a Chennai railway station about six months ago, prior to boarding the Pandian Express to Madurai.
He said Venkatesan arrived at the station in a high-end Mercedes-Benz car wearing branded attire and shoes, which initially led him to mistake the MP for a corporate executive.
"He claims to be a communist leader, you know? But he comes in a high-end Benz car, wears branded everything, and I don't know whether the book royalties will sustain such a lifestyle," Justice Swaminathan remarked targeting Venkatesan, who is also a writer.
The war of words began after Justice Swaminathan, speaking at a recent book launch event, commented on the alleged fraudulent book procurement for the Periyar Arivulagam Library in Coimbatore and suggested in a lighter vein that spiritual books on the late Kanchi Shankaracharya ought to be placed on the empty shelves (since the controversial books were withdrawn) as an "atonement" for the wrongdoing.
Reacting to the comment, Venkatesan on Sunday criticised the judge, arguing that library procurement fraud was a crime of corruption that must be punished by law. The CPI (M) leader stated that punishing corruption is the duty of a judge, whereas prescribing atonement for sins is the job of astrologers, leading to Swaminathan's remarks on Monday.
(This story has not been edited by THE WEEK and is auto-generated from PTI)