Kolkata, Nov 17 (PTI) TMC MP Abhishek Banerjee on Tuesday refused to retract his criticism of the judiciary after the Calcutta High Court issued him a show-cause notice for criminal contempt, claiming that a section of the judiciary was yielding to pressure from the BJP and questioning alleged differential treatment of saffron party leaders.
Returning from Delhi, he said he had the right, as an elected representative, to question judicial decisions and the functioning of constitutional institutions, asserting that his remarks had been misinterpreted as an allegation that individual judges were affiliated with the BJP.
"I am questioning a section of the judiciary, not the judiciary as a whole. What I said was that a section works under influence. I never said that judges were in an alliance with the BJP. There is a clear difference between saying that judges belong to the BJP and saying that a section of the judiciary is under pressure from the BJP," the TMC national general secretary said.
Banerjee said he believes that many judges were impartial and neutral, but maintained that the conduct of certain courts raised questions about equal treatment under the law.
"I am also a public authority as an elected MP. I have the right to question judicial verdicts. The Constitution of the country and the people who elected me have given me that right," he said, asserting that he was not someone who would bow down in the face of intimidation.
Earlier in the day, the high court ordered the issuance of a show-cause notice to Banerjee, holding that his statements and a social media post targeting the court amounted to "ex facie criminal contempt". The court directed him to respond within 15 days of the issuance of the notice.
Explaining the basis of his criticism, Banerjee cited what he described as contrasting judicial responses to cases involving BJP leaders and those associated with the TMC.
"When an FIR is filed against Suvendu Adhikari during his tenure as Leader of the Opposition, a stay order is granted, but that does not happen in my case. The rules should be the same for everyone, but they are not. I ask why proceedings are stayed when an FIR is registered against him, while proceedings are not stayed when an FIR is registered against me," he said.
The Diamond Harbour MP also referred to former TMC leaders Mukul Roy and Arjun Singh, alleging that both received judicial protection after switching political allegiance and joining the BJP.
He claimed that his personal assistant had been implicated in false cases and sent to jail, while aides of BJP leaders had received protective court orders.
Banerjee also cited former Calcutta High Court judge Abhijit Gangopadhyay, who later joined the BJP and became an MP.
"We saw the example of Abhijit Gangopadhyay in the Calcutta High Court in 2024. In an interview, he himself acknowledged that he had been in contact with the BJP while serving as a sitting High Court judge," the TMC leader said.
Questioning the functioning of the judiciary in matters involving powerful individuals and ordinary citizens, Banerjee cited an industrialist's legal move against the media.
"When a top industrialist approaches the Calcutta High Court seeking an injunction against the media or a particular report, the mentioning, listing, hearing and passing of an order can all happen within a single day. But when an ordinary citizen approaches the court, that person has to wait for three to six months," he alleged.
The TMC leader also questioned why BJP leaders Nishikant Dubey and Biplab Kumar Deb had not faced contempt proceedings over their past remarks against the judiciary.
He further alleged that Adhikari, during his tenure as Leader of the Opposition, would repeatedly predict judicial orders and announce their likely impact well in advance, but was never subjected to contempt proceedings.
Banerjee also questioned why Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar had not faced contempt proceedings over the alleged non-compliance of the Election Commission with Supreme Court guidelines during the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of electoral rolls.
He claimed that the poll panel had disregarded the apex court's directions, including those concerning randomisation, and said the TMC had approached the issue of its agitation in Delhi on the basis of its faith in the judiciary.
"We lost Bengal because we had complete faith in the Supreme Court. The Election Commission did not follow the directions and guidelines issued by the court, yet Gyanesh Kumar has not faced contempt action," he alleged.
The TMC leader also referred to the Supreme Court's guidelines on post-poll violence in West Bengal, claiming that six months had passed without their implementation by the state government and questioning why no action had been initiated against the state's home minister, chief secretary, DGP or the Kolkata Police commissioner.
Banerjee also referred to an incident on November 7, when he alleged that his residence had been attacked, claiming that a molestation case was subsequently registered against him.
"I was attacked at my home, yet a molestation case was filed against me. There were around 50 television cameras present, and the complainant was also there. I question why one person is sent to jail in a case while another receives a stay from the court," he said.
He maintained that his criticism was directed at what he perceived as unequal treatment and not the institution as a whole.
"I believe everyone must be equal before the law, before judges and before the judiciary. There cannot be one rule for me and different rules for Nishikant Dubey, Suvendu Adhikari, Biplab Deb or other leaders or Gyanesh Kumar simply because they belong to the BJP," he said.
Noting that he continues to have faith in the judiciary, Banerjee said its impartiality must be reflected in its actions and not merely in its pronouncements.
(This story has not been edited by THE WEEK and is auto-generated from PTI)