Can a country become a modern democracy while continuing to police its citizens with a colonial mindset? That is the uncomfortable question running through Yashovardhan Azad's Policing the Republic, an account that examines India's law-enforcement machinery not merely through the crimes it investigates but through the power it exercises, the institutions it answers to and the rights it is expected to protect.

Azad, a 1976-batch IPS officer who rose to become Special Director of the Intelligence Bureau and later Secretary (Security) in the Cabinet Secretariat, writes from a vantage point few commentators possess. However, this is not simply a retired police officer's recollection of an eventful career. It is an attempt to understand why a system entrusted with protecting the Republic often struggles to shed its colonial inheritance.

The book's opening chapter, 'The Politics of Corruption', sets the tone. Beginning with his early posting as Superintendent of Police in Sehore in 1980, Azad moves from personal encounters with corruption to its deeper historical and political roots. His argument is that corruption cannot be understood simply as an individual's moral failure. It thrives when institutions become vulnerable to political influence, and accountability is replaced by patronage.

This institutional weakness becomes more apparent in his examination of police reforms. Nearly two decades after the Supreme Court's landmark Prakash Singh judgment of 2006, the resistance of governments to meaningful reform has remained a recurring concern. Azad recounts how attempts to monitor implementation ran into bureaucratic differences and political reluctance. The result is a police force expected to uphold the law while remaining vulnerable to those who exercise political authority.

His chapter on the new criminal laws is particularly relevant. The replacement of the colonial-era criminal statutes promised a significant overhaul, but Azad asks whether legislative change alone can deliver justice. He flags concerns about expanded police discretion under the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, vague definitions of organised crime and the possibility of arbitrary interpretation. He also points to inadequate forensic infrastructure, gaps in investigation and the absence of sufficient safeguards for vulnerable individuals.

The distinction between changing the law and changing the culture of law enforcement is central to the book. New provisions and technological mandates mean little when police stations lack the infrastructure, training and resources to implement them effectively.

Azad's treatment of crime against women and custodial safeguards further exposes the distance between legal promises and institutional delivery. His discussion raises questions about investigative accountability, victim protection and the persistent delays that undermine public confidence in the criminal justice system.

The book becomes particularly engaging when it moves into India's internal security landscape. Its accounts of Kashmir, Maoist insurgency and Manipur are informed by Azad's experience in the security establishment. Rather than viewing these conflicts exclusively through the prism of counterterrorism, he brings attention to their political, social and administrative dimensions. His account of highway blockades and extortion in Manipur, for instance, illustrates how prolonged institutional failures can turn ordinary life into a casualty of conflict.

An unexpected but revealing dimension emerges in the chapters on privacy and the Right to Information. Having served as Central Information Commissioner and delivering more than 8,000 judgments, Azad brings first-hand experience to the tensions between state secrecy and citizens' right to know. His account of a dispute involving the CRPF and the Ministry of Home Affairs illustrates how even statutory transparency can encounter resistance from within government.

This transition from policing the citizen to holding the state accountable is perhaps the book's most interesting underlying thread.

The narrative is ambitious, occasionally moving across subjects at a pace that leaves some issues deserving greater exploration. A stronger account of the ordinary citizen's experience inside police stations and the criminal justice system would have added another layer to its institutional critique.

Yet, the book succeeds in raising a question that goes beyond policing: who holds the holders of power accountable? Azad's answer lies in institutional independence, professional policing, transparency and constitutional restraint.

Book: Policing the Republic: An Inside View of How India Fights Corruption and Crime, and Protects Rights

Author: Yashovardhan Azad

Publisher: Bloomsbury

No. of pages: 270

Price: ₹699

Disclaimer: Comments posted here are the sole responsibility of the user and do not reflect the views of THE WEEK. Obscene or offensive remarks against any person, religion, community or nation are punishable under IT rules and may invite legal action.