On Tuesday, Union Power Minister R.K. Singh downplayed a report by a US cyber-security company that a massive power outage in Mumbai was a result of a cyber attack by China.
Singh was quoted by Live Mint as saying, "There is no evidence to prove that the October 2020 electricity blackout in Mumbai was caused by a cyber attack perpetrated by China or Pakistan." Singh claimed the outage was caused by human error.
The report by Recorded Future claimed malware was inserted into the Indian power grid last year. The New York Times reported the power outage may have been a warning to India from China amid the military standoff in Ladakh.
On Wednesday, BJP MP Subramanian Swamy played up the risk of Chinese cyber attack and linked it to a key issue that he has raised repeatedly: India's purchase of the S-400 surface-to-air missile system from Russia.
Swamy tweeted, "After getting a taste of the damage China can do by cyber war, can we rely on S-400 anti aircraft weapon? China can make it fizzle." The statement "China can make it fizzle" appeared to mean the possibility of China hacking into the S-400 system to render it ineffective.
Swamy has been a critic of the S-400 purchase. The Narendra Modi government signed a deal worth over $5 billion in 2018 to buy the S-400, which combines radars, control equipment and multiple types of surface-to-air missiles of varying ranges to shoot down practically any aerial target—aircraft, drones, bombs, cruise missiles and ballistic missiles.
China was the first export customer of the S-400. In December 2019, Swamy had warned the presence of Chinese electronics would make the missile system "compromised" in a war with Pakistan. In June 2020, Swamy warned the Modi government "would be well advised not to use S-400 in a possible battle with China. This is because S-400 is made with Chinese electronics".
In January this year, Swamy warned that going ahead with the S-400 deal would turn out to be a blunder by the Modi government.
- India to make 1 billion vaccine doses for Indo-Pacific, with Quad aid
- India, China continue talks, urge dialogue to bring about complete disengagement
- 'India will become cannon fodder for US': Chinese media on Quad summit
- 'Should shed mutual suspicion': Ahead of Quad meeting, China's conciliatory hand
While Swamy's views on the S-400 may be interpreted by some as alarmist, China does supply a wide range of electronic components used for aerospace programmes worldwide. Such components could potentially be used as means for implanting malware and tracking and espionage systems. Moreover, western experts have previously warned the S-400's sensors could pick up classified information of sensitive systems such as the F-35 stealth fighter. This has been among the reasons cited by the US for its continued opposition to Turkey and India buying the S-400 missile system.