DELAYED PAYMENTS from the Indian Air Force has landed the once debt-free Hindustan Aeronautics Ltd in a spot. By the end of this year, HAL’s dues will balloon to Rs20,000 crore, crippling its ability to carry out day-to-day operations. Its financial woes have given ammunition to the opposition, which had been targeting the Narendra Modi government for having bypassed the public-sector company to award offsets related to the Rafale deal to Anil Ambani’s Reliance.
“The financial situation at HAL would have been different if the Rafale offsets were given to it. It is a huge contract,” T. Suvarna Raju, former chairman and managing director of HAL, told THE WEEK. Insiders say HAL, which has paid Rs5,000 crore to the defence ministry in dividends in the past four years, had to borrow around Rs1,000 crore recently to pay salaries to its 30,000 employees.
The crisis at HAL has intensified the war of words between Defence Minister Nirmala Sitharaman and Congress president Rahul Gandhi. Rahul alleged in Parliament that the government had favoured Reliance at HAL’s expense. Sitharaman retorted that the government had given HAL contracts worth Rs1 lakh crore, and that the Congress was weeping crocodile tears.
The fight soon spilled out to Twitter, with Rahul challenging Sitharaman to produce documents in Parliament on the orders worth Rs1 lakh crore. Sitharaman tweeted photos of the documents in reply: “It’s a shame that the president of @INCIndia is misleading the nation. HAL has signed contracts worth Rs26,570.8 crore (between 2014 and 2018) and contracts worth Rs73,000 crore are in the pipeline. Will @RahulGandhi apologise to the country from the floor of the house?”
While the government may yet contain the Rafale fallout, the HAL issue could become the next political hot button. Sitharaman recently called HAL chairman R. Madhavan to Delhi to discuss the issues plaguing the company. Madhavan apparently told her about the workload status at each of HAL’s nine units across India. According to sources, the production line at the Sukhoi complex in Nashik will be inactive once it delivers the pending batch of 23 Sukhoi jets to the Air Force in early 2020. With no further orders in place, more than 5,000 employees of the unit will be without work.
The 3,000 personnel at HAL’s Bengaluru division, too, have no orders to look forward to after they finish upgrading the Air Force’s Jaguar and Mirage aircraft. They could well be transferred to the Tejas unit, also in Bengaluru, which is building 83 light combat aircraft.
“We are getting squeezed,” said Suryadevara Chandrasekar, chief convenor of the coordination committee of HAL trade unions. “First, we are not getting confirmed orders, though there are so many orders in the pipeline. The only visible orders are for 83 light combat aircraft and 15 light combat helicopters. The value of both contracts is only Rs53,000 crore. Second, we are not getting the dues from the Air Force.”
According to Chandrasekar, HAL can produce products worth Rs2 lakh crore a year. “But we have come down to the level of taking overdrafts from banks to pay salaries,” he said. “Our image in the market is coming down.”
The situation does not bode well for the Air Force, which depends on HAL for aircraft spares and service. The Air Force is already struggling to sustain its operational capacity—the number of fighter squadrons have come down from 42 in 2002 to 32 at present. The figure will be 28 in 2020, if the government does not take drastic measures.
With the government battling the Rafale controversy, the proposal to buy 110 medium combat aircraft is in limbo. The Air Force had issued a request for information (RFI) early last year, to which six global companies responded. “After RFI, there has been no movement on the proposed acquisition,” said a source. “Everybody is busy tackling the Rafale issue.”
In Parliament and outside, the government and the opposition have been trading barbs over defence deals. In response to Rahul’s Rafale-related allegations, the government has highlighted the alleged corruption in the AgustaWestland helicopter deal, which was signed and then scrapped by the previous, Congress-led government. The arrest of Christian Michel, the alleged middleman in the deal, and his statements have helped the government attack the Congress.
Sitharaman recently gave a lengthy speech in Parliament rebutting the Congress’s allegations. She said the current deal for buying 36 Rafale fighters was far better than the one negotiated by the Congress to purchase 126 jets. According to her, the basic cost of the aircraft had come down by 9 per cent under the new deal, and that the delivery time was reduced by five months. She said the new deal also ensured performance-based logistics support for all 36 jets, without additional cost. “We don’t do defence deals,” she said. “We deal in defence, with national security as our priority.”
But Sitharaman’s spirited defence has failed to satisfy the Congress. Rahul has promised to launch a criminal inquiry into the Rafale deal if his party comes to power after the Lok Sabha elections. He also alleged that Prime Minister Narendra Modi was “running away” from the questions posed to him, including the ones related to HAL and its financial woes.
“I am not accusing the defence ministers (Sitharaman and Manohar Parrikar, who was defence minister when the Rafale deal was signed),” said Rahul. “I am accusing Modi of involvement in the Rafale scam. You (Sitharaman) did nothing but defend the deal.”