The recent miscarriage of a translocated tigress at Buxa Tiger Reserve has sparked intense debate among wildlife experts regarding the planning, protocol adherence, and scientific rigor of tiger reintroduction programs in India.

The recent miscarriage of a translocated tigress at Buxa Tiger Reserve has sparked intense debate among wildlife experts regarding the planning, protocol adherence, and scientific rigor of tiger reintroduction programs in India.

The recent miscarriage of a translocated tigress at Buxa Tiger Reserve has sparked intense debate among wildlife experts regarding the planning, protocol adherence, and scientific rigor of tiger reintroduction programs in India.

West Bengal’s ambitious plan to bring tigers back to the forests of North Bengal has been overshadowed by an incident involving a translocated tigress. ‘Dooars Rani’ (T-138), a three-year-old tigress brought from Bihar’s Valmiki Tiger Reserve to Buxa Tiger Reserve, has reportedly suffered a miscarriage, losing all three foetuses. While the National Tiger Conservation Authority (NTCA) and the Wildlife Institute of India (WII) have initiated inquiries, the incident has raised questions about the planning and execution of the translocation.

Was the tigress already pregnant when she was captured? Were the prescribed protocols followed during her capture, transportation and release? More importantly, was the operation rushed to meet an administrative deadline rather than guided by the animal's biological needs?

Wildlife experts are now examining a series of decisions that may have exposed the tigress to unnecessary stress. One of the primary concerns is the possibility that she was already in the early stages of pregnancy when she was captured in Valmiki. Detecting pregnancy in a wild tigress during its initial weeks is extremely difficult without prior mating records or appropriate diagnostic assessments. Experts believe that the physical stress associated with capture, chemical immobilisation, long-distance road transportation and subsequent handling could have affected the pregnancy. However, the precise cause of the fetal loss will have to be established through a proper veterinary investigation.

The questions do not end there. According to experts familiar with wildlife translocation procedures, the tigress reportedly lost her radio collar, necessitating another round of darting and chemical immobilisation. This has raised concerns about the quality of the initial collaring and the technical arrangements made before the animal was moved.

There are also questions about the temporary holding arrangements. Experts point out that an enclosure without adequate protective boarding and other necessary safeguards can expose a recovering animal to injury. A disoriented or stressed tiger attempting to escape after regaining consciousness may damage its claws, teeth and other body parts against unsuitable enclosure surfaces. Such precautions are particularly important when handling a large carnivore in unfamiliar surroundings.

For many conservationists, the Buxa episode brings back memories of the failed tiger reintroduction programme at Odisha’s Satkosia Tiger Reserve. That initiative was derailed by inadequate preparation, local resistance, and operational difficulties. The concern now is whether the lessons from Satkosia were adequately incorporated into the subsequent translocation programme.

R. Sreenivas Murthy, a retired Indian Forest Service (IFS) officer who spearheaded the successful tiger reintroduction programme in Panna Tiger Reserve, believes Panna's success cannot be replicated simply by moving animals from one forest to another. The groundwork, he argues, is what makes the difference.

"People have not learnt from the debacle in Satkosia," Murthy said, reacting to the Buxa episode. "Tiger reintroduction is not that easy as everybody generally thinks. That dedication, that preparation, that sincerity of monitoring without disturbing the animal—that has to be there, and things shall not be dictated from the top."

His observations point to a larger concern in wildlife conservation: the growing tendency to measure a project's success by its launch rather than its eventual outcome. A tiger's release may make for an impressive public event, but it says little about whether the habitat is ready, whether the animal can adapt and whether the conditions for successful breeding exist.

Murthy believes that field preparedness, trained personnel and the confidence of local communities must be established well before an animal is brought into a new habitat. A translocation, he cautions, should never be treated as a ceremonial exercise.

"Reintroduction is not a train where you show a green flag and start it," Murthy remarked. "There is no need for any celebration to release an animal; celebrate only after breeding success is achieved."

Meanwhile, the incident has triggered a public campaign, ‘Justice for Dooars Rani’, led by wildlife conservationist Avijan Saha, project coordinator of conservation group Airabot. The campaign is demanding a transparent investigation and accountability from the authorities involved in the operation.

Saha has questioned the decision to release the tigress without what he describes as the customary 15-to-20-day soft-release acclimatisation period. He has also raised concerns about whether her pregnancy was adequately assessed before the translocation and whether the availability of a resident female tiger population in Buxa was properly considered while planning the programme.

"In human society, killing foetuses is a punishable crime under the law—so what about a Schedule-I animal like a tiger? Who will take responsibility for this loss?" Saha asked. He also questioned whether pressure to demonstrate an early conservation success had influenced decisions that should have been guided entirely by scientific considerations.

The ongoing inquiries must now establish what happened at every stage of the operation. This includes the initial capture and collaring in Valmiki, veterinary assessments, transportation, temporary confinement and the eventual release in Buxa.

For now, the most pressing question is not when another tiger will be brought to Buxa, but whether authorities are prepared to establish what went wrong with the first operation—and ensure that the same mistakes are not repeated.