Prime Minister Narendra Modi recently criticized Indian industry leaders for failing to increase domestic investments, expand business capacity, and boost job creation despite benefiting from significant government sops and tax reforms.

Prime Minister Narendra Modi recently criticized Indian industry leaders for failing to increase domestic investments, expand business capacity, and boost job creation despite benefiting from significant government sops and tax reforms.

Prime Minister Narendra Modi recently criticized Indian industry leaders for failing to increase domestic investments, expand business capacity, and boost job creation despite benefiting from significant government sops and tax reforms.

Prime Minister Narendra Modi is hopping mad at Indian corporates. But the irony is that the premier may still have been playing nice, only breezing over the real issue.

As Indian industry’s leading honchos lined up eager-beaver at business chamber FICCI’s centenary celebrations on Thursday, they were hoping for perhaps another round of ‘Viksit Bharat’ pep talk from Modi, and maybe even some concession announcement. But to their horror, the prime minister let loose publicly and in unwavering terms the government’s frustration with India Inc not playing ball.

“India's growth story is creating new opportunities; Our industries must be ready to seize them,” PM Modi had started off his speech in his usual style, before moving into some hard realities. “Our domestic market must not become our comfort zone; It should provide us with the confidence to compete in global markets; Therefore, invest in understanding the needs of customers across different regions of the world.”

The sting came when PM Modi openly asked the question that has been swirling for some years now with economists and industry watchers — why the many pro-business reforms by the Modi-Sitharaman combine have not translated into investment being ploughed into capacity expansion, new projects and, in correlation, in a language everybody knows way too well after the GenZ-awakening — into jobs and salary growth.

The PM mentioned some of the salient sops to the industry, right from the corporate tax rate cut in 2018, the Atmanirbhar Bharat restructuring and policy relaxations in many sectors announced during the peak of the pandemic and the income tax relief for up to 12 lakh rupees. Then he moved in for the kill: “Did you increase the salaries of your employees? Did you increase the number of employees? No. The attitude remains: Modiji, you do it, we will see.”

The government’s frustration is palpable, and it was even expressed earlier by the finance minister at similar business fora. The general trend over the past several years has been of corporate India making use of the government sops to score record profits and comfortable dividends for its stakeholders, even while doing the bare minimum when it came to the ‘return gift’ expected by the authorities: using the money made to increase production, expand business and jack up the employment market.

Sadly, that is, generally speaking, yet to happen. The initial argument was that demand wasn’t there, spurring the government to cut GST as well as raise the income tax ceiling.

But industry continued in its merry ways, with barely any significant increase in new white-collar jobs. Salary growth has been lagging behind indicators like GDP growth and that of the stock market indices.

For example, the latest Q2 earnings announced by listed companies show that, on average, profit growth has been in the range of 30% year-on-year; yet, average nominal salary hikes are just at 9%, with price rise (inflation) at a level above the Reserve Bank’s limits, the increase in real money in hand comes to just 2.91 per cent.

There is also another worry for the mandarins around Central Vista. At least some big corporations have been taking their newfound profits overseas. The official reason has been ‘going global’ and ‘taking on the world’ and all, but at least some government observers aren’t too sure, connecting it to the recent flight of foreign investment from the country.

While the PM softened his blow by asking India Inc to make use of the opportunities, the message was clear. While some believe that industry’s fresh demand for sops as part of recent pre-budget consultations was what set him off, other experts believe this outburst was a long time in coming.