CBI court in Keralam acquits CPI M leaders P Jayarajan T V Rajesh in 2012 murder case
Kochi, Nov 19 (PTI) A Special CBI court here on Thursday acquitted CPI(M) strongman P Jayarajan, former party MLA T
Kochi, Nov 19 (PTI) A Special CBI court here on Thursday acquitted CPI(M) strongman P Jayarajan, former party MLA T
Kochi, Nov 19 (PTI) A Special CBI court here on Thursday acquitted CPI(M) strongman P Jayarajan, former party MLA T
Kochi, Nov 19 (PTI) A Special CBI court here on Thursday acquitted CPI(M) strongman P Jayarajan, former party MLA T V Rajesh and 16 others in the 2012 Ariyil Shukoor murder case, while sentencing seven of the 13 convicted to life imprisonment and the remaining six to two years in jail.
Additional Special Judge (CBI) Sabarinathan P also acquitted Syamjith, son of CPI(M) state secretary M V Govindan.
The court acquitted Jayarajan and Rajesh, who were accused of conspiring to murder Shukoor, saying that the prosecution has not succeeded in proving that a criminal conspiracy was hatched by them.
It said that there was no direct oral evidence to prove the alleged criminal conspiracy, as several of the witnesses, on this aspect, were given up by the prosecution and a couple of them did not turn up to testify despite repeated notices from the court.
"Further, the prosecution has not collected the call detail records in respect of the mobile numbers of accused No 32 (Jayarajan) and 33 (Rajesh), who according to the prosecution are parties to the conspiracy".
"Reckoning the above aspects, I am of the considered view that the available evidence before the court is insufficient to prove the prosecution case that the accused hatched criminal conspiracy from room No 315 of Co-operative Hospital, Taliparamba to assault and commit murder of Shukkoor," the judge said in his 360-page judgement.
"Accordingly, I find that the prosecution has not succeeded in proving the guilt of the accused Nos 32 and 33 beyond reasonable doubt for the offences charged against them," the judge added.
At the same time, the court was also of the considered view that there were no serious lapses on the part of the investigating officers, so as to affect the root of the prosecution case and "absolutely there are no serious flaws as well to discard the prosecution case as false".
Of the 13 convicted, seven were found guilty of murder under section 302 of the IPC and sentenced to life imprisonment, while the remaining six were convicted under section 452 (house-trespass after preparation for hurt, assault or wrongful restraint) and punished with two-year jail terms.
The prosecution, during the arguments on sentence, sought the maximum punishment -- death penalty -- for those convicted under section 302 of IPC.
However, the court was of the view that as there was no evidence that it was a politically motivated murder, as contended by the prosecution, and having regard to the age of the accused/convicts, their family backgrounds, etc., "this case cannot be considered as a 'rarest of rare' to impose the death sentence on them".
"I am satisfied that imposition of the alternative sentence of imprisonment for life would strike the right balance between the conflicting interests of the accused and the public at large and go a long way towards sustaining public confidence in our legal system," the judge said.
Of the seven sentenced to life, the court imposed a fine of Rs 1 lakh each on two of them and Rs 1.35 lakh each on the remaining five.
In the case of the six sentenced to two years, the court imposed a fine of Rs 10,000 on each of them.
The court said that out of the total Rs 9.35 lakh fine imposed on the convicts, Rs 5 lakh should be paid as compensation to the victim's mother if the amounts are recovered from them.
The sentences were pronounced later in the day, and the six who received two-year jail terms were granted bail.
In its judgement, the court said that, in the manner in which the accused persons committed acts of violence which resulted in the death of Shukkoor and caused bodily injuries to two others, they are "not entitled to get the benefit of the benevolent provisions of the Probation of Offenders Act".
"They deserve punishment," the judge said.
Earlier, CBI prosecution assistant K Padmanabhan told reporters outside the court that the prosecution was not fully satisfied with the verdict, especially with the acquittal of the second accused Ganesh.
"The prosecution is very disappointed over that outcome as he is one of the two persons who stabbed the victim -- Shukoor," Padmanabhan said.
Therefore, the prosecution will go for an appeal on this aspect, he added.
The court acquitted Ganesh because the witnesses had failed to identify him during the test identification parade.
The case relates to the murder of Muslim Youth League activist Shukoor in Ariyil area of Kannur district in February 2012.
According to the CBI chargesheet, the killing was allegedly carried out in retaliation for an attack on Jayarajan, who was then the CPI(M) Kannur district secretary.
The prosecution has alleged that the conspiracy to murder Shukoor was hatched while the leaders were staying at a cooperative hospital.
(This story has not been edited by THE WEEK and is auto-generated from PTI)