After Trump's midterm rout Europe sees cracks in populist right. It may not stop France's Le Pen

Paris, Nov 7 (AP) A decade ago, US President Donald Trump's victory sent a populist shock wave across the West. Now, Europe is asking whether the midterm rout of his Republican Party will send one back.

    European opponents of right-wing populism see the US vote as the latest sign of its faltering advance. Since April, voters have ousted Hungary's Viktor Orban, ended Aleksandar Vucic's long grip on Serbia and blocked the Bolsonaro family's return in Brazil.

    “When cracks in power become more visible, this can trigger a cascade effect,” said Peter Kreko, director of Budapest's Political Capital Institute.

    Nowhere would such a cascade matter more than in France, where nationalist Marine Le Pen is the front-runner in a presidential election six months away that could put the European Union's only nuclear arsenal, and a UN Security Council veto, in far-right hands.

    The populist right's recent defeats could rattle the woman vying to become France's first Madame la Presidente. But the anger punishing populists in power from Budapest to Belgrade could carry her to it — precisely because her National Rally party has never governed France.

    Le Pen also faces a legal cliffhanger. France's highest court aims to rule on her appeal against an embezzlement conviction by early April, just weeks before the first round of voting; if it rules against her, she could campaign and face voters wearing an electronic tag.

    “She could still be barred from running, and now Americans delivered this sort of rebuke to Trump's kind of populism,” said Carmen Artaza, 31, a Paris resident educated in the United States. “That's bound to rattle her — unsettle her campaign.”

    But in France, "the far right still has the wind in its sails,” said Sciences Po political scientist Gilles Ivaldi.

    Analysts say voters who handed Democrats control of the US House and Senate may have punished Trump's record, especially on the economy, more than his “America First” ideas.

    Populists are still winning some elections, too: Such candidates have taken presidencies in Poland, Chile and Colombia since mid-2025.

     A string of defeats since last year

     -----------------------------------------

     “The trend toward the far right has been the defining feature of 21st-century politics,” said Daphne Halikiopoulou, a politics professor at Britain's University of York.

    But lately, defeats for the illiberal populist camp have been piling up.

    “The midterms are a very favourable result for the centre left, and this could hinder the far right,” she said.

    Leaders or parties espousing nationalist, anti-immigration policies have suffered at least eight national election setbacks in roughly 18 months: in Romania, the Netherlands, Portugal, Hungary, Sweden, Serbia, Brazil and now the United States.

    And many were emphatic: Portugal elected moderate Socialist Antonio Jose Seguro over hard-right populist Andre Ventura by two to one; Hungary ended Orban's 16 years in power; Serbia's Vucic conceded defeat last month to a student-led protest movement; and Romania chose pro-European centrist Nicusor Dan over nationalist George Simion.

    Last month, Brazilian President Luiz Inacio Lula da Silva narrowly beat Flavio Bolsonaro, son of former President Jair Bolsonaro.

    Other votes thinned the ranks of anti-immigration parties. Geert Wilders' party lost 11 seats in the Netherlands as the centrist party surged. In Sweden, the hard-right Sweden Democrats lost 11 seats as the left-leaning opposition won a narrow majority.

    The results “show clearly that far-right politics are not popular,” said Aurelien Mondon, a politics expert at Britain's University of Bath.

    Even some on the populist right see a pattern. The US midterms “join the defeats of Bolsonaro and Orban,” Markus Frohnmaier, a senior lawmaker with the far-right AfD, wrote on X.

     All eyes on France

     -----------------------

     Each defeat can make the next one easier to imagine. Voters need to believe that “an increasingly authoritarian regime with vast resources can be defeated,” Kreko said. “The midterm results helped create that sense.”

    The French left seized on the result, while the far right gave it a Gallic shrug.

    “There is no inevitability in politics,” said Raphaël Glucksmann, the French centre-left presidential candidate, calling it “a message of hope for all.”

    The National Rally, which cheered Trump's return to power last year, is now keeping him at arm's length.

    “What happens in other countries is none of my business,” party president Jordan Bardella told RTL radio.

    Sebastien Chenu, who leads the far-right party's lawmakers in the National Assembly, called the vote “a rejection of Donald Trump's policies” in a statement to The Associated Press, blaming inflation and fuel prices driven by a war with Iran “that he himself started.”

    In Germany, AfD co-leader Alice Weidel blamed “the disastrous consequences of the Iran war.”

    The message from Europe's nationalists: The defeat was Trump's, not theirs.

    After three failed bids, Le Pen has never looked stronger, according to French pollsters.

    Yet the race to be her main challenger is wide open, with hard-left leader Jean-Luc Melenchon, centre-right former Prime Minister Edouard Philippe and Glucksmann among the contenders.

     Losing votes, shaping the agenda

     ----------------------------------------

     “Losing an election is definitely a sign of decline. But it's not sudden death,” Halikiopoulou said. “In many cases, far-right parties are losing because their competitors are adopting their positions."

    In Britain, Labour hardened its stance on immigration, especially under former Prime Minister Keir Starmer, to fend off Nigel Farage's Reform UK.

    In France, the Senate last week approved a bill from President Emmanuel Macron's government that could make anyone who knowingly joins a violent group pay up to 10,000 euros (USD 11,200) for what others destroy, and let the state dock family benefits to cover it — long a Le Pen idea.

    The real danger, Mondon said, is “the failure of the mainstream elite” to counter the far right. A decade under Macron has brought “the mainstreaming of far-right talking points.”

     Le Pen's advantage: She has never governed

     ---------------------------------------------------

     For Le Pen, the lesson of the midterms may be less that populists lose than that incumbents do.

    Anger at incumbents has been building for years. In 2024, for the first time since records began, every governing party that faced a national election in a developed country lost vote share, according to ParlGov, a University of Bremen database.

    The far right is rising where it sits in opposition and centrists rule, as in France, Austria and Germany, where the AfD took a record 43.8 per cent in Saxony-Anhalt's state election in September.

    Anger and a hunger for radical change, embodied by both Le Pen and Melenchon, now dominate French politics, Ivaldi said.

    The election will show whether there is “still a barrier against the far-right,” he said. Voters across the political spectrum rallied behind Macron to block her in 2017 and 2022.

    For now, he said, France “could well experience its own 'Trump moment,' like the US in 2016.”

    Voters have shown they can turn populists out of power. France will show whether they can keep one from winning it.

    Halikiopoulou put it simply: “Were the midterms a massive blow to Trump? Yes. Were they important? Absolutely. But the fact remains that Trump is still in power.” (AP)

GRS

GRS

(This story has not been edited by THE WEEK and is auto-generated from PTI)