Why is that a woman in power is always expected to know her place?
The Kallakurichi controversy suggests that the distance between celebrating women in leadership and accepting their authority remains considerable
Recent controversies involving the harassment of female administrators in Tamil Nadu expose a deep-seated political paradox regarding women in power, testing the government's commitment to true empowerment and accountability.
Recent controversies involving the harassment of female administrators in Tamil Nadu expose a deep-seated political paradox regarding women in power, testing the government's commitment to true empowerment and accountability.
Recent controversies involving the harassment of female administrators in Tamil Nadu expose a deep-seated political paradox regarding women in power, testing the government's commitment to true empowerment and accountability.
This is my second opinion piece in the past one month on the women in power being abused and mentally harassed. I was disturbed and moved when I wrote my weekly column after Chennai mayor Priya was being trolled and abused on social media. But that was social media, which can be shut down and closed whenever someone doesn’t want to read or watch. But in the past one week, the news headlines in Tamil Nadu is continuously occupied by what has happened to an IAS officer. The images being shared and the trolls that abuse a woman in the name of saving their own MLA has exposed how Tamil Nadu has had a complicated relationship with women in positions of power.
A state that has celebrated a woman chief minister, produced women bureaucrats who have commanded respect across the country and placed women in important administrative positions seems to be very backward still in dealing with women in power. The allegations against Kallakurichi MLA C. Arul Vignesh, who is accused of sending inappropriate messages to district collector J.E. Padmaja, are serious. The legislator has denied the allegations. While the facts will have to be established through an impartial investigation, the political response to the controversy is revealing in itself.
A district collector is not an extension of a politician or a MLA’s constituency office. She is the district’s administrative head, entrusted with implementing government policy, enforcing the law and taking decisions that may not always please those in power. Her position does not become negotiable because the person on the other side of the table has an electoral mandate.
Tamil Nadu apparently knows better. It has seen this battle play out since the days of J. Jayalalithaa. The former chief minister was hardly someone who needed reminding that women could command power. She fought a deeply patriarchal political establishment, survived public humiliation and built an authority that few male contemporaries could challenge. Her political career was, in many ways, a lesson in how difficult it is for a woman to occupy the highest office without constantly having her authority questioned. In fact I have even admired the days when men used to queue up in front of her and fall on her feet.
But gone are those days and Jayalalithaa’s legacy, according to me, presents a paradox. In a patriarchal society, a woman at the top doesn’t automatically translate into a political culture that respected women at every level. The ability to accept a woman as chief minister is not necessarily the ability to accept a woman collector who refuses to bend to a local MLA.
The issue is not whether Padmaja is a woman officer who needs protection. It is whether she can discharge her duties without having to negotiate her dignity, personal safety or professional independence. Women do not enter public service to spend their careers proving that they deserve the chair they occupy.
Equally telling is the political instinct to defend, dismiss or trivialise allegations before an investigation has run its course. Calling the controversy a media trial or describing the accused legislator as ‘paavam’(sympathising him) does little to inspire confidence. Political loyalty cannot become a substitute for accountability.
For Chief Minister Vijay, this is an early test of the political culture he wants to establish. A government cannot speak of women’s empowerment at public functions and remain ambivalent when a woman in its own administration faces allegations of harassment involving a ruling-party legislator.
Jayalalithaa had to fight to be taken seriously in a man’s political world. Decades later, a woman collector should not have to fight the same battle in the district she administers. The real measure of women’s empowerment is not how many women occupy powerful positions. It is whether the men around them have learnt to respect the power those positions carry. And of course to me the Kallakurichi controversy suggests that the distance between celebrating women in leadership and accepting their authority remains considerable.