From Kohima to Arlington: Why sanctity of war memorials must endure
A sentinel at the Tomb of the Unknown Soldier reprimanded Pete Hegseth at Arlington National Cemetery, upholding solemnity, duty, and military honour
Remembrance Day traditions of solemn silence and reflection were recently disrupted at Arlington National Cemetery when US Secretary of War Pete Hegseth breached protocol by posing for photographs and laughing near the Tomb of the Unknown Soldier. Alerted by the inappropriate behavior, sentinel Specialist Thomas Iglesias courageously rebuked the group, reminding all visitors of the mandatory respect owed to fallen heroes. This incident underscores the stark contrast between political arrogance and the sacred sacrifice commemorated at global war memorials.
Remembrance Day traditions of solemn silence and reflection were recently disrupted at Arlington National Cemetery when US Secretary of War Pete Hegseth breached protocol by posing for photographs and laughing near the Tomb of the Unknown Soldier. Alerted by the inappropriate behavior, sentinel Specialist Thomas Iglesias courageously rebuked the group, reminding all visitors of the mandatory respect owed to fallen heroes. This incident underscores the stark contrast between political arrogance and the sacred sacrifice commemorated at global war memorials.
Remembrance Day traditions of solemn silence and reflection were recently disrupted at Arlington National Cemetery when US Secretary of War Pete Hegseth breached protocol by posing for photographs and laughing near the Tomb of the Unknown Soldier. Alerted by the inappropriate behavior, sentinel Specialist Thomas Iglesias courageously rebuked the group, reminding all visitors of the mandatory respect owed to fallen heroes. This incident underscores the stark contrast between political arrogance and the sacred sacrifice commemorated at global war memorials.
When you go home, tell them of us and say, for your tomorrow, we gave our today.” This evocative epitaph watches over the Kohima War Cemetery, where lie the fallen Allied soldiers of the 1944 Battle of Kohima. I learnt an early lesson in reverence at such places in November 1981. A gardener tending to the flower beds among the gravestones looked up as I passed by. “You are fortunate to be here,” he said. “A very auspicious hour, when all the souls gather here. You will feel their presence in the silence. It is the eleventh hour of the eleventh day of the eleventh month.”
That was the hour in 1918 when the armistice between Germany and the Allied powers came into effect and the guns fell silent along the western front. Armistice Day gradually acquired a wider meaning: as another World War added millions more to the roll of the dead, it became Remembrance Day and now in different geographies it honours all those who have died in several conflicts across generations; in America, it is Veterans Day.
Ceremonies, along with narratives of the victors and the vanquished, vary. There is the presence of royalty at the London Cenotaph, the buglers sound the last post at Menin Gate in Ypres, the eternal flames burn at India Gate or outside the Kremlin Wall, the letters and flowers spell grief at the sombre Vietnam War Memorial in Washington. But one theme runs across them all: the sound of silence. In this silence even the most powerful confront their mortality, heads are bowed, a mood of reflection takes over. The pain of young lives brutally cut short is strewn amidst the idealism of supreme sacrifice. Nations come face to face with the cost of their history; individual sacrifice transforms into collective memory.
The Arlington National Cemetery is an iconic site. Thousands of its identical white marble headstones stretch across the Virginia hillside. There is a message in the uniformity: in death, distinctions of rank and privilege recede; presidents lie alongside ordinary soldiers. At its heart stands the Tomb of the Unknown Soldier whose sentinels belong to the third US Infantry Regiment known as the Old Guard. These superbly trained, highly motivated soldiers guard the tomb in rain or snow, observing a meticulously choreographed and precise pattern. They carry no rank, only that of Specialist, and they take their guardianship seriously.
But all this is double Dutch and gobbledygook to Pete Hegseth, Fox newscaster-turned secretary of war, hounded by personal and institutional controversies: charges of alcoholism, the mind-boggling ‘Signalgate’, the senseless purging of senior generals, the attack on diversity and women in the military, the disastrous Iran war. His cultivated image, in contrast: patriot supreme down to Stars and Stripes pocket poche, muscled macho overdosed on testosterone, superman of white military values.
On November 11, this image splintered. Freshly exuberant from surviving a half-baked impeachment attempt, Hegseth callously breached the solemnity of the ceremony at Arlington’s Tomb of the Unknown Soldier: he cockily posed for photographs on the steps of the monument with his wife and friends. They bantered and giggled; someone cackled with the tinkle of wealthy arrogance. The sentinel on duty, Specialist Thomas Iglesias halted his measured march and loudly scolded the secretary of war and his friends: “All visitors will maintain an atmosphere of silence and respect at all times.” The group slinked away sheepishly. Hegseth, in damage control mode, honoured Iglesias the following day.
Speaking truth to power is not complicated. All it takes is a belief in the right thing and the willingness to pay the necessary price for defending it.
The author was India’s high commissioner to the UK and ambassador to the United States.