The first-ever trilateral summit between the leaders of the United States, China, and Russia in Shenzhen concluded with a symbolic four-point declaration on global security and nuclear risk reduction, yet produced no substantive progress on major international conflicts like Ukraine and Iran.

The first-ever trilateral summit between the leaders of the United States, China, and Russia in Shenzhen concluded with a symbolic four-point declaration on global security and nuclear risk reduction, yet produced no substantive progress on major international conflicts like Ukraine and Iran.

The first-ever trilateral summit between the leaders of the United States, China, and Russia in Shenzhen concluded with a symbolic four-point declaration on global security and nuclear risk reduction, yet produced no substantive progress on major international conflicts like Ukraine and Iran.

The first-ever trilateral meeting of the leaders of the United States, China and Russia was billed as a historic moment in global diplomacy. But the summit in Shenzhen, held on the sidelines of the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC) gathering, ended with little substance beyond a four-point declaration on peace and international security. Donald Trump, Xi Jinping and Vladimir Putin agreed to cooperate on UN reform, energy security, nuclear risk reduction and the jurisdiction of international institutions. Yet they made no substantive progress on the wars in Ukraine and Iran, two of the most pressing conflicts involving the three powers. The meeting was less about resolving these crises than about the political and diplomatic advantages each leader could derive from sharing the same platform.

The comparisons with the 1945 Yalta conference, where the Allied leaders discussed the post-war international order, were always going to be difficult to sustain. Shenzhen had the spectacle of a historic gathering, but little of the diplomatic preparation or strategic purpose that made Yalta consequential. The meeting lasted barely over an hour and produced no detailed roadmap for addressing the conflicts and rivalries that divide the three countries. Its significance lay instead in the symbolism: the leaders of the world’s three most powerful nuclear-armed states sitting together and presenting themselves as custodians of global stability. But beneath the carefully choreographed display were competing ambitions and sharply divergent understandings of the international order.

For Trump, the summit offered an opportunity to project himself as a global dealmaker. He appeared comfortable sharing the stage with Putin and Xi, both of whom he has sought to engage through personal diplomacy. Yet the approach also exposed the limitations of his transactional view of international relations. A summit can create the appearance of common purpose, but it cannot by itself reconcile strategic interests that have little in common. Trump had hoped to use the gathering to advance discussions on Ukraine, Iran and nuclear arms control. The final declaration, however, offered no concrete commitments on any of these fronts.

For Putin, the meeting was an important diplomatic gain. Russia’s invasion of Ukraine had left Moscow facing Western sanctions and sustained efforts by European governments to isolate it internationally. The Shenzhen gathering offered the Russian president an opportunity to appear in the company of the American and Chinese leaders as an equal participant in discussions on the future of global governance. It also reinforced his argument that Russia remains an indispensable power in international affairs. The declaration’s emphasis on state sovereignty and the immunity of state officials from the jurisdiction of international institutions was particularly significant for Moscow. Putin faces an arrest warrant issued by the International Criminal Court over alleged war crimes in Ukraine. The three leaders’ criticism of what they described as the abuse of jurisdiction by international tribunals gave the Kremlin an opportunity to challenge the legitimacy of institutions that have sought to hold it accountable. The summit did not end Russia’s isolation from the West, but it provided Putin with a powerful image of diplomatic acceptance.

Xi, meanwhile, had the advantage of being the host and setting the terms of the encounter. Bringing the American and Russian presidents to Shenzhen allowed him to project China as a central player in efforts to shape a new international order. The imagery of the three leaders meeting on Chinese soil also served Beijing’s ambition to present itself as an indispensable centre of global diplomacy. But the show of unity concealed the tensions that continue to define US-China relations. Washington and Beijing remain locked in a contest over advanced technology, artificial intelligence, semiconductor exports and access to critical minerals. American restrictions on China’s access to advanced chips and Beijing’s leverage over rare-earth supplies have become important instruments in this rivalry. The fragile trade understanding reached earlier in Busan has offered some breathing space, but it has done little to resolve the underlying economic and technological competition. The Shenzhen meeting produced no visible breakthrough on these issues either.

The most consequential element of the declaration may have been the agreement to begin trilateral dialogue on reducing nuclear risks and preventing proliferation. It marked an important departure from the traditional bilateral framework of nuclear arms negotiations between Washington and Moscow, bringing Beijing formally into the discussion. All three leaders reiterated the principle that a nuclear war cannot be won and must never be fought. But the declaration stopped well short of establishing an arms-control framework. It contained no targets for reducing warheads, no verification arrangements and no timetable for negotiations. The expiry of the New START treaty earlier this year has further complicated an already uncertain nuclear landscape. China is expanding its nuclear arsenal, while the United States and Russia continue to possess the world’s largest stockpiles. Whether the three governments can translate their broad agreement into meaningful negotiations remains an open question.

The summit also raised questions about the future of America’s relationships with its traditional allies. European governments, already concerned about Trump’s approach to the Ukraine war, have watched his willingness to engage Putin with considerable unease. The absence of any meaningful commitment on Ukraine in the Shenzhen declaration will do little to reassure Kyiv or its European supporters. Washington’s willingness to engage Moscow and Beijing directly is not, in itself, a departure from diplomacy. The concern is that such engagement could take place without adequate consultation with allies whose security interests are directly affected. The contrast between the attention devoted to the three-power gathering and the uncertainty surrounding American commitments to its partners has added to anxieties in Europe and parts of Asia.

The Shenzhen summit may eventually be remembered as an important moment in the evolution of relations among the three powers. But its immediate achievements were limited.