Malik's refusal to speak on his earlier Indus Water Treaty threat also comes a day after India's Ministry of External Affairs clarified that New Delhi's stance on the issue remains unchanged.

Malik's refusal to speak on his earlier Indus Water Treaty threat also comes a day after India's Ministry of External Affairs clarified that New Delhi's stance on the issue remains unchanged.

Malik's refusal to speak on his earlier Indus Water Treaty threat also comes a day after India's Ministry of External Affairs clarified that New Delhi's stance on the issue remains unchanged.

Pakistani minister Musadik Malik on Sunday dodged questions on terrorism and the Indus Waters Treaty (IWT), sparking a new row over his controversial visit to India on the sidelines of the Shanghai Cooperation Organization (SCO) Civilisational Dialogue in New Delhi.

When asked if he regretted his earlier IWT-linked threat on "cutting off hands", the climate change minister simply said that he "hadn't been invited" to discuss the Indus Waters Treaty, and that he could speak on the topic only if he got an invite.

"When you invite me to discuss the Indus Water Treaty, we will certainly talk about it," he told reporters.

"I am your guest, you are my hosts ... You have asked me a question 100 times and I have responded with the same answer 100 times. If you ask me this 500 more times also, my answer will remain the same," he added.

This comes months after Malik had spoken about Pakistan's stance on the IWT, which was placed in abeyance in the wake of the deadly Pahalgam attack of April 2025, India's Operation Sindoor in May that year, and the hostilities between the nuclear neighbours in the weeks that followed.

"We've proved that if anyone lays a hand over our share of water, we'll cut off that hand," he had said, referring to India's IWT move as an attempt to "control" the entirety of Pakistan's food security, half its employment and a quarter of its economy.

Malik also used the same tactic to handle a question on terrorism, saying that it could be discussed only during bilateral talks, when evidence can be presented.

"Whenever (terrorism-linked) discussions take place, they should be based on evidence. I assure you, such discussions will certainly happen ... We have stated on many occasions—in various forums—that evidence can be presented bilaterally; we have also suggested that this could be handled multilaterally—you bring your evidence, and we will bring ours," he said.

Warning that Islamabad would respond if someone were to provoke it, he added that his country was also a victim of terrorism.