Nearly 14 years after the murder of IUML activist Ariyil Abdul Shukkoor, a special CBI court acquitted senior CPI(M) leaders P. Jayarajan and T.V. Rajesh of conspiracy charges while convicting 13 others, sparking fresh political controversy and plans for an appeal in Kerala.

Nearly 14 years after the murder of IUML activist Ariyil Abdul Shukkoor, a special CBI court acquitted senior CPI(M) leaders P. Jayarajan and T.V. Rajesh of conspiracy charges while convicting 13 others, sparking fresh political controversy and plans for an appeal in Kerala.

Nearly 14 years after the murder of IUML activist Ariyil Abdul Shukkoor, a special CBI court acquitted senior CPI(M) leaders P. Jayarajan and T.V. Rajesh of conspiracy charges while convicting 13 others, sparking fresh political controversy and plans for an appeal in Kerala.

Nearly 14 years after the murder of Ariyil Abdul Shukkoor, a 24-year-old Indian Union Muslim League activist in Kannur, a Special CBI Court in Ernakulam on November 19, 2026, acquitted senior CPI(M) leaders P. Jayarajan and T.V. Rajesh of the conspiracy charges that had long defined the political significance of the case. CBI Additional Special Judge P. Sabarinathan found 13 persons—all linked to the CPI(M)—guilty. Seven of them were found guilty of murder under Section 149 IPC and sentenced to life imprisonment.

However, the court also acquitted 18 others, including CPI(M) state secretariat member P. Jayarajan. The court held that the prosecution had failed to prove beyond reasonable doubt that Jayarajan (then Kannur district secretary) and Rajesh (then MLA), along with others, had hatched a criminal conspiracy on February 20, 2012, at the Co-operative Hospital in Taliparamba to target Shukkoor in retaliation for an earlier attack on their vehicle.

The split verdict—convictions for those alleged to have carried out the killing and acquittals for the two most prominent political figures—has immediately reopened old fault lines in Kerala's politics. For the victim's family and the IUML, the failure to establish the conspiracy has been a disappointment and grounds for appeal. For the CPI(M), it removes a long-standing legal cloud over two senior leaders. The judgment's emphasis on evidentiary gaps, rather than an affirmative finding of innocence on the merits, has itself become a point of contestation.

The CPI(M) is treating the acquittals as vindication. Jayarajan and Kannur district secretary K.K. Ragesh have described the conspiracy case as a "political hatchet job" or "fabricated" by the then UDF government and the IUML to target the CPI(M), create mistrust among minorities, and sustain a media campaign for 14 years. They have demanded an apology from the UDF and IUML. The verdict allows the party to argue that its senior leaders were not directing the violence.

Nevertheless, the convictions of party cadres remain a liability for the red party. The CPI(M) has not distanced itself from those found guilty. State secretary M.V. Govindan acknowledged that both the convicted and acquitted were party workers and said the party would pursue the necessary legal steps. M.V. Govindan's own son, Syamjith, was also among the 18 individuals acquitted by the court.

Several of those convicted of murder had links to CPI(M)-controlled institutions. This reinforces long-standing opposition claims about cadre involvement in political violence and retaliatory attacks in Kannur, often described as a form of "parallel court".

However, the verdict gives the party leadership breathing room and a talking point—that the conspiracy charge against its senior leaders collapsed—while the convictions bring the party's baggage of political violence back into public memory.

The victim's family, including his brother and mother, and the IUML's Kannur unit have described the verdict as disappointing and unexpected. They have indicated that they will appeal, particularly against the acquittals of the leaders. Senior IUML figures such as P.K. Kunhalikutty have maintained that the murder was planned and argued that the failure of several witnesses to appear raises questions about possible intimidation. Chief Minister V.D. Satheesan also expressed reservations about the verdict, saying that all those involved in the crime should be punished and promising that the legal fight would continue.

Incidentally, the CPI(M)'s claim that the case was used to alienate minorities will continue to be tested against the family's and the UDF's insistence that justice remains incomplete.

For the UDF, the case will continue to serve as a means of reminding the public of alleged CPI(M)-linked retaliatory violence in Kannur, particularly since the murder followed an attack on the vehicle carrying Jayarajan and Rajesh. The "kangaroo court" narrative that circulated for years also remains politically useful, even if the court did not uphold the allegation of a conspiracy involving the party's senior leadership.