Mercedes, Marxism and Mahaperiyava: The war of words between Su Venkatesan and Justice G.R. Swaminathan
The confrontation originated over remarks regarding an alleged book procurement irregularity at the Periyar Arivulagam library
A major controversy has erupted between CPI(M) MP Su. Venkatesan and Madras High Court Justice G.R. Swaminathan following a dispute over public library book procurement irregularities and a subsequent exchange involving personal remarks about the MP's lifestyle and official travel entitlements.
A major controversy has erupted between CPI(M) MP Su. Venkatesan and Madras High Court Justice G.R. Swaminathan following a dispute over public library book procurement irregularities and a subsequent exchange involving personal remarks about the MP's lifestyle and official travel entitlements.
A major controversy has erupted between CPI(M) MP Su. Venkatesan and Madras High Court Justice G.R. Swaminathan following a dispute over public library book procurement irregularities and a subsequent exchange involving personal remarks about the MP's lifestyle and official travel entitlements.
A war of words between CPI(M) MP Su. Venkatesan and Madras High Court Justice G.R. Swaminathan has escalated into a political and judicial controversy, with the Communist Party of India (Marxist) demanding action against the judge over what it termed an unwarranted personal attack on the Madurai MP.
The controversy, which began over the alleged irregularities in the procurement of books for public libraries in Tamil Nadu, took a personal turn on Monday when Justice Swaminathan questioned Venkatesan's communist credentials, referring to his alleged use of a Mercedes-Benz, branded clothes and First AC train travel.
The exchange followed Venkatesan’s criticism of the judge’s remarks at a recent book launch function concerning the alleged fraudulent procurement of books for the Periyar Arivulagam library in Coimbatore. Justice Swaminathan had suggested that books on the late Kanchi Shankaracharya, popularly known as Mahaperiyava , could be placed on the shelves vacated by the disputed publications as an act of atonement. Taking exception to the suggestion, Venkatesan said irregularities in public library procurement amounted to corruption and those responsible should be punished under the law. While punishing corruption was the responsibility of a judge, prescribing atonement for sins was the job of astrologers, Venkatesan remarked.
During a contempt petition hearing on Monday, Justice Swaminathan clarified that his earlier suggestion was made in jest. However, he took strong exception to the Venkatesan’s remarks on his judicial responsibilities and recalled an encounter with Venkatesan at Chennai railway station before boarding the Pandian Express to Madurai.
The judge said the MP had arrived in a Mercedes-Benz, wore branded clothes and shoes and travelled First AC, while he himself was travelling in sleeper class. He also questioned whether book royalties could support such a lifestyle. Venkatesan hit back on Tuesday, describing the observations as a “cheap personal attack.” He clarified that he did not own a car and that the Mercedes-Benz was not his. Defending his first AC travel, he said it was covered by the official travel entitlement of a Member of Parliament. “Travelling in first AC does not make a person’s views wrong. Travelling in sleeper class does not make their words right,” he said, asserting that people should be judged by their ideas and actions rather than their clothes or mode of transport.
The CPI(M) state secretary P. Shanmugam condemned the judge’s remarks and urged the Chief Justice of the Madras High Court to take appropriate action, alleging a breach of judicial propriety. The party also reiterated its concerns over the judge's public statements and ideological positions.
The confrontation comes amid an ongoing investigation into the library procurement scam. The DVAC has registered an FIR and arrested publisher R. Mohan. The High Court has also sought a detailed probe into library procurement over the past two decades and a government white paper. The case is now set to be heard again on November 20, even as the political fallout from the exchange continues to widen.