Delhi smog and myopia: Why keeping children indoors could affect their eyesight
We tend to treat myopia as an inconvenience that a pair of glasses solves. The earlier it begins, the further it usually progresses, and high myopia raises the lifetime risk of retinal detachment, glaucoma and early cataract
Childhood myopia is surging across urban India, driven by increased screen time and prolonged indoor restrictions during Delhi's smog season that deprive developing eyes of crucial natural light
Childhood myopia is surging across urban India, driven by increased screen time and prolonged indoor restrictions during Delhi's smog season that deprive developing eyes of crucial natural light
Childhood myopia is surging across urban India, driven by increased screen time and prolonged indoor restrictions during Delhi's smog season that deprive developing eyes of crucial natural light
Every November, Delhi carefully looks at the AQI. Last winter, the Supreme Court and the Air Quality Commission went further and asked schools across NCR to keep children off the field for all of November and December.
I am an eye surgeon, and I support every one of those orders. But these orders could make them short-sighted. Not all of them, and not overnight. But the evidence is now too strong to leave in a footnote.
Myopia, in which the eyeball grows too long and distant things blur, has many causes: genes, hours of close work, screens. The strongest protection we know of is the time outdoors, and researchers increasingly think the reason is not the exercise or the fresh air. It is the light.
The gap between indoors and outdoors is far bigger than anyone can imagine. When researchers measured a regular classroom at a school in Guangdong, the median reading was 477 lux. The open ground outside
read 19,500. We never notice, because the eye adjusts in seconds. The retina notices. Bright light releases dopamine in it, and dopamine is one of the signals that tells a growing eye to stop lengthening.
This is not a hunch. In Guangzhou, a randomised trial added a single 40-minute outdoor class to the school day. Over three years, 30.4 per cent of those children became myopic, against 39.5 per cent in schools that
carried on as usual. Taiwan went further. Poor eyesight among its primary schoolchildren climbed from 34.8 per cent in 2001 to 50 per cent in 2011. In 2010 the government began asking every primary school to
get children outdoors for 120 minutes a day. Within a few years the line turned down.
India’s line is still climbing. Across eight Indian studies covering 28,600 children, myopia among urban 5 to 15-year-olds rose from 4.44 per cent in 1999 to 21.15 per cent in 2019. Projected forward, it reaches about 48 per cent by 2050. Nearly half of urban India’s schoolchildren.
Delhi’s own numbers are less comfortable still. When AIIMS screened nearly 10,000 schoolchildren in the city, 13.1 per cent were myopic, and three out of four of them were not wearing the glasses they needed. Think about what that means in a classroom. A child who cannot read the board looks exactly like a child who is not paying attention. Some of the children we call careless or slow simply cannot see.
And the more we spend on schooling, the worse it appears to get. The same AIIMS team found myopia more common in Delhi’s private schools than in its government ones. In a rural North Indian district, the gap was stark: 10.1 per cent of private-school children against 1.4 per cent in government schools. Parents are paying for longer hours, more tuition and earlier tablets. Their children’s eyes are settling part of the bill.
Now add the smog season. We take the age group whose eyes are most sensitive, keep them indoors for weeks, and put many of them in front of a screen for online class. We have seen this experiment before.
After Chinese schools closed in early 2020, screening of 1.2 lakh children in Feicheng found 21.5 per cent of six-year-olds myopic. In none of the previous five years had that figure gone above 5.7 per cent. Older children, who had spent more hours in online class, barely changed. The six-year-olds lost daylight at the age when it matters most. Delhi repeats a smaller version of that every winter. Nobody measures the result.
We tend to treat myopia as an inconvenience that a pair of glasses solves. It is not. The earlier it begins, the further it usually progresses, and high myopia raises the lifetime risk of retinal detachment, glaucoma and
early cataract. And there is no undoing the growth itself. By adulthood the eye stops lengthening, and whatever length it reached stays for life.
Glasses, lenses and laser can correct the blur; none of them shortens the eye or removes those risks. The only window to change its course is childhood, and most of childhood is spent in a classroom. So I am not arguing against GRAP. I am arguing that it has a blind spot. It treats 'outdoors' as one thing to be switched off. For the lungs, outdoors means exertion. For the eyes, it means light. The two can be separated, and the rules should separate them.
Five changes to make
1) Bring the light inside. Blinds up, every light on, and children rotated through the window rows, because daylight falls away quickly from the glass. The Guangdong team built a glass-roofed classroom with a median of 2,540 lux, five times a normal room, and both children and teachers preferred it. Delhi’s new school buildings should be designed with that in mind.
2) Use the shade. A Taiwanese trial found that time in corridors and under trees, at around 1,000 lux and above, still slowed myopic change. The courts were worried about children running and breathing hard. A seated reading period in a covered verandah is not a football match, and Delhi’s
particulate levels tend to ease in the afternoon. That is when to hold it.
3) If young children must study online, keep screen sessions short and tell parents to move the desk to the brightest window in the house.
4) Give the light back. Children who lose November and December should get a compulsory outdoor period through February and March, when the air clears.
5) Count it. A vision screening for every Delhi schoolchild each January would tell us, for the first time, what our winters cost.
It took us years, and several court orders, to start measuring the air our children breathe. The light they see deserves the same attention. Their eyes are already keeping count.
(The author is a Delhi-based ophthalmologist)
The opinions expressed in this article are those of the author and do not purport to reflect the opinions or views of THE WEEK.