Change your name to ‘Ram Pal’: Cleric bashes Javed Akhtar after lyricist praises Ram as a moral and cultural ideal
Akhtar's remarks describing Lord Ram as an ideal transcending religious boundaries drew criticism from a Muslim cleric who questioned the atheist lyricist's motives
Veteran Bollywood lyricist Javed Akhtar sparked a debate by praising Lord Ram as a cultural ideal and a moral symbol transcending religious boundaries, drawing criticism from a Muslim cleric while receiving staunch defense from political leaders regarding his freedom of expression.
Veteran Bollywood lyricist Javed Akhtar sparked a debate by praising Lord Ram as a cultural ideal and a moral symbol transcending religious boundaries, drawing criticism from a Muslim cleric while receiving staunch defense from political leaders regarding his freedom of expression.
Veteran Bollywood lyricist Javed Akhtar sparked a debate by praising Lord Ram as a cultural ideal and a moral symbol transcending religious boundaries, drawing criticism from a Muslim cleric while receiving staunch defense from political leaders regarding his freedom of expression.
Veteran Bollywood lyricist, screenwriter and poet Javed Akhtar, an avowed atheist, praised Lord Ram as a moral and cultural ideal. As an outspoken personality, he is often seen sharing his views on religion, politics, rationalism and secularism. While talking about the music in the latest blockbuster Ramayana, Akhtar recalled his lines from the 2004 movie Swadesh, “Mann se Ravan jo nikale, Ram uske mann mein hai”. Here, Akhtar said that Lord Ram was not merely a person but an idea, morality, aesthetics and a way of life. He further stated that Ram is in every Indian's blood, regardless of religion, and represents values that transcend religious boundaries.
Javed Akhtar’s remarks, however, triggered criticism from a Muslim cleric, Maulana Sajid Rashidi, President of the All India Imam Association, who questioned Akhtar’s motives and challenged the consistency of his atheism with his praise of Lord Ram. Rashidi hinted that Akhtar may have commercial motives, and that his family's involvement in the film industry influenced his position. In a sharper remark, Maulana Sajid suggested that Akhtar change his name to ‘Ram Pal’ to gain respect among Hindus, accusing him of trying to “straddle two boats” rather than taking a clear stand. The controversy subsequently became a debate over whether religious figures can be appreciated outside the boundaries of one's own faith.
Through a secular lens, appreciation of Ram by a Muslim or an atheist need not be an act of religious conversion, appeasement or commercial calculation; it can be an expression of shared cultural heritage. Under Article 25 of the Indian Constitution, an atheist’s freedom of conscience—including the choice not to believe in any religion—should be respected as fully as a believer’s freedom to profess and practise a religion. Neither is required to justify their personal beliefs to express cultural appreciation.
Congress and Samajwadi Party leaders Udit Raj and Rajiv Rai defended Akhtar's right to share his views, noting that everyone is entitled to their own interpretation, supporting the freedom to express different perspectives while acknowledging the religious significance of the Ramayana.