Is the American dream fading? Why Indian students are reassessing US degrees
Growing uncertainty over student work authorisations, tighter H-1B rules and strict immigration policies are making Indian families reassess the value of a US education and career
Indian students and professionals pursuing education and employment in the United States face unprecedented immigration hurdles, lengthy visa delays, and proposed fee hikes, prompting families to reevaluate American universities and explore alternative global destinations.
Indian students and professionals pursuing education and employment in the United States face unprecedented immigration hurdles, lengthy visa delays, and proposed fee hikes, prompting families to reevaluate American universities and explore alternative global destinations.
Indian students and professionals pursuing education and employment in the United States face unprecedented immigration hurdles, lengthy visa delays, and proposed fee hikes, prompting families to reevaluate American universities and explore alternative global destinations.
For Akshay Mhatre, returning to India was never part of the plan. The 22-year-old from Pune had spent four years pursuing an undergraduate degree in economics at a US university. By his third year, having overcome initial homesickness and adjusted to a different culture, he was convinced he wanted to stay on after graduation. But finding a job proved considerably harder than he had anticipated.
Akshay had failed to secure internships in the US and had to complete his summer internships in India. Eight months before graduation, he began applying for jobs, sending out hundreds of applications and attending a handful of interviews. “I got a couple of interviews, but the moment I mentioned that I am an international student and I do not have experience in the US, it was like an automatic rejection,” he says.
He applied for Optional Practical Training (OPT) in April this year, paying around $500 in application fees and another $1,700 for premium processing, which was supposed to guarantee a decision within 30 working days. The deadline passed without a response. Repeated attempts to contact the US Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS) yielded little. Unable to work legally while waiting for authorisation, Akshay eventually decided to return to India permanently.
Sumit Mahajan, a graduate of an Ivy League university, faced a similar predicament. Six months after graduation, his OPT application remained stuck in processing. “Rather than refreshing that page every morning, it’s easier to close the door on the US for now and perhaps revisit it in the future, when circumstances are better,” he says.
Their experiences reflect a growing dilemma for Indian families. For generations, a US degree has promised global exposure and lucrative career opportunities. But the assumption that students can graduate, find employment and eventually settle in the country is becoming increasingly difficult to sustain.
Education counsellors are noticing a change in how families approach overseas education. Anjana Anand, senior career and college counsellor at PSG Clifton International School, says the US is no longer the automatic first choice for some families, although the aspiration to attend Ivy League institutions remains strong. “Families are scrutinising the investment more closely: ‘If we are spending this much, should it be for anything less than a globally top-ranked institution?’” she says.
Richa Dwivedi Saklani, founder and principal counsellor at Inomi Learning, describes the shift as a change in confidence rather than a loss of faith in American education.
THE PRICE OF STAYING
The latest source of anxiety for students is the US Department of Homeland Security’s proposal to impose a $70,000 fee for an initial OPT recommendation and $30,000 for subsequent recommendations. Under the existing system, international students studying in the US on F-1 visas can apply for up to 12 months of OPT employment related to their field of study. Graduates in science, technology, engineering and mathematics (STEM) disciplines can seek an additional 24-month extension. OPT is not a work visa but a temporary employment authorisation that allows eligible graduates to gain practical experience.
Another route to internships, Curricular Practical Training (CPT), is also facing tighter scrutiny. CPT allows F-1 students to undertake internships or practical training directly related to their course, provided these are an integral part of their academic curriculum.
The proposed fee would be payable by educational institutions before they recommend students for OPT. The initial $70,000 would apply when a university recommends an F-1 student for OPT for the first time, while a further $30,000 would apply to subsequent recommendations, including a STEM extension. Although universities would be responsible for paying the fees, the proposal allows them to pass the costs on to students or employers. The proposal has not yet become law.
Restrictions on practical training are already affecting universities. On November 9, Brown University, in Providence, Rhode Island, announced that it was indefinitely suspending CPT for undergraduate students following tighter federal interpretations of eligibility. Its revised guidance, updated on November 13, limits CPT to programmes where internships or practicums are mandatory for graduation. At Brown, only six master’s programmes currently meet the requirement. The decision illustrates how students could lose access to internship opportunities even before graduation.
For Indian families, already grappling with a weakening rupee, rising tuition fees and expensive accommodation, the possibility of another financial barrier is unwelcome. Even a one- or two-year postgraduate programme at a leading American university can involve an investment of Rs50-80 lakh or more.
Noida-based Vikram Singh, 49, is planning to send his son to the US for a master’s degree in engineering. He is considering universities such as Purdue and Georgia Tech, with an estimated expenditure of around Rs50 lakh, financed through family savings and an education loan. “When we started planning, our main concerns were securing admission and arranging the loan. Now, there is something new in the news almost every other day. My biggest worry is what happens if my son completes his degree but is unable to find a job,” he says.
Neha Bansal, 23, has applied for a master’s programme at Carnegie Mellon University. She estimates that her education will cost more than Rs80 lakh. “Even after spending so much money, over Rs80 lakh in my case, if you are forced to return home without gaining practical exposure in the US or getting a meaningful return on your investment, the plan may not be worth it,” she says.
Even graduates who secure employment authorisation face further hurdles. Kartik Subramaniam from Chennai received his OPT approval after approximately four months. But when he explored the O-1 visa, designed for individuals with extraordinary ability in their professional fields, he received conflicting advice from immigration lawyers. Some recommended applying, while others suggested waiting until he had accumulated more professional achievements. "My OPT application taught me patience. My O-1 journey taught me something even more valuable: confidence in my own preparation. Professional advice is important, but so is understanding your own story and believing in the work you have put in," he says.
A WIDER IMMIGRATION CRACKDOWN
The OPT proposal is part of the Trump administration’s broader effort to tighten immigration rules and restrict the use of foreign workers. In a presidential proclamation issued in September 2025, Trump accused employers of exploiting the H-1B programme to replace American workers with lower-paid foreign employees.
The administration has also sought to impose a $100,000 payment requirement for certain new H-1B petitions involving workers outside the US. Although the White House extended the restriction for another year in September 2026, federal courts subsequently blocked its enforcement. As of November 17, the payment requirement is not enforceable.
On October 8, Vice President JD Vance announced investigations into alleged H-1B and J-1 visa fraud. He said the administration had suspended the PERM labour certification process for several leading companies following an investigation into their employment practices. PERM is a key stage in the process through which employers sponsor foreign workers for permanent residency.
The administration also announced investigations into nine universities over their use of J-1 visas for foreign researchers and graduate students. The DHS proposal on OPT reflects the same emphasis on scrutiny, arguing that the programme has become vulnerable to fraud and abuse. Its accompanying document states: “The F-1 visa was never intended to provide a pathway to employment in the United States.”
The November 3 midterm elections dealt Republicans a severe setback, with Democrats winning control of both the House of Representatives and the Senate. Yet Trump has shown little inclination to change course. He named Stephen Miller, one of the principal architects of his hawkish immigration policies, as the new White House chief of staff, suggesting that immigration restrictions will remain central to the administration’s priorities despite the electoral setback.
THE H-1B AND GREEN CARD DILEMMA
The difficulties facing international students are compounded by the concerns confronting Indian professionals already working in the US. For many graduates, the conventional route involves securing OPT, finding an employer willing to sponsor them and subsequently entering the H-1B system. Even those who obtain H-1B visas can face years of uncertainty while waiting for employment-based green cards.
Teena Sebastian, who is from Thiruvananthapuram, moved to the US on an H-1B visa three years ago. Working as an onsite lead for an Indian IT contracting company, the 34-year-old says the professional opportunities have come with considerable personal sacrifices. She has not seen her parents since moving to the US. “That separation is not merely a calendar entry; it is an emotional toll that manifests in sudden mood swings, rising stress, and an underlying ache that never quite recedes,” she says.
As an unmarried woman, she values the independence and distance from intrusive social scrutiny that living abroad affords her. But even a visit to India has become stressful because of the possibility of visa stamping delays or administrative difficulties preventing her return. “If I cannot return, what happens to the life left behind? My apartment is tied to a formal lease agreement that cannot just vanish. I bought a car that still has EMIs to be cleared. Losing an income stream here, there is no way to resolve those financial commitments from across the ocean,” she says.
The uncertainty has also begun influencing corporate sponsorship decisions. On November 10, IBM announced that it would discontinue US visa and green card sponsorship for the majority of positions in its consulting division, which employs more than 1.5 lakh people. According to reports, affected employees have been given the option of relocating to IBM positions outside the US or leaving the company by the end of 2026. The decision highlights how even established professionals can find their long-term prospects unsettled, beyond the challenges of obtaining an H-1B visa.
For Sudeep Mathew and his wife Manju, who have lived in California for nearly 16 years, the wait for permanent residency continues. Both moved to the US on H-1B visas. Their green card priority date is January 2014 (the exact time the USCIS officially receives your initial green card paperwork), yet they are still waiting. Their experience illustrates how even professionals who have spent much of their working lives in America remain uncertain about their long-term future there.
The woes could deepen following a fresh proposal notified by the US Department of Labour on November 17. Under the proposal, employers that have laid off American workers within the preceding two years would be barred from seeking certification for foreign workers for similar positions. It also proposes to end an exemption that currently allows employers to sponsor professional nurses and physical therapists without undergoing the standard labour market test. The proposal is particularly significant for Indian professionals in health care and technology, as well as those hoping to transition from temporary work visas to permanent residency. For applicants already facing long backlogs, the prospect of additional recruitment requirements and employer restrictions adds another layer of uncertainty.
LOOKING ELSEWHERE
The changing immigration environment is beginning to influence the choices of students who have not yet left India. According to the Institute of International Education’s Open Doors 2026 report, the US hosted 3,39,435 Indian students during the 2025-26 academic year, down 6.5 per cent from 3,63,019 in the previous year. Across all nationalities, new international student enrolments in the US declined by 17.7 per cent.
The slump is already straining US university finances, as full-tuition international students heavily subsidise financial aid and campus services for US citizen students—with research showing every international undergraduate at a public university opens up two spots for American students. Politico reports that individual institutions are already feeling the squeeze: Ohio State University reported a nearly 13 per cent drop in international enrolments to a 16-year low, the University of Washington’s Seattle campus hit a decade low, and Illinois Institute of Technology plans to borrow up to $200 million from its endowment to offset the shortfall.
Anand says families are exploring universities in Europe, Hong Kong and Singapore, besides English-taught programmes in Japan and international branch campuses. Saklani identifies the UK, Ireland, the Netherlands, France and Spain as destinations attracting greater interest. Hong Kong and Canada, which had lost some of their appeal among prospective students, are also being reconsidered. Saurabh Arora, chief executive of University Living, a student accommodation marketplace, says students are also exploring Germany, Spain, Italy, France and the UAE. Arora, meanwhile, argues that countries like the US have a legitimate interest in protecting their domestic employment markets and that students should not assume an overseas qualification automatically guarantees a job.
Families are also increasingly hedging their bets by applying to Indian institutions. Some are considering new-age private universities and undergraduate programmes offered by the Indian Institutes of Management. An Indian undergraduate degree followed by a postgraduate qualification abroad is emerging as a more financially prudent option for some.
THE ATTRACTION ENDURES
Yet it would be premature to conclude that the American Dream has disappeared. The US continues to offer some of the world’s most prestigious universities, advanced research facilities, strong industry connections and opportunities for professional development that remain difficult to replicate elsewhere. Saklani believes the overseas education market will continue to grow with India’s expanding middle class. “For students seeking quality education and exposure abroad, changes in political conditions and visa laws do not have a particularly negative impact,” she says.
Hyderabad-based Andrew D’Souza, who is preparing to join the University of Chicago, remains committed to studying in the US despite the uncertainty. “My primary motivation for pursuing a degree in the US remains the quality of education, global exposure and the skills I will gain,” he says. “I understand that work opportunities in the US may become more competitive. So, I am looking at the future with a balanced approach, while remaining hopeful about the prospects there."
The names of some students have been changed at their request.
With Nirmal Jovial and Shubhangi Shah.