How Sonia Gandhi's memoir 'Belonging' dispels UPA rumours, paves way for Rahul Gandhi
‘Belonging’ softens Sonia Gandhi’s image and might get critics to look at the Congress more sympathetically
Sonia Gandhi's memoir Belonging blends her personal life story with reflections on Indian political history, addressing past controversies and highlighting Rahul Gandhi's leadership role within the Congress party.
Sonia Gandhi's memoir Belonging blends her personal life story with reflections on Indian political history, addressing past controversies and highlighting Rahul Gandhi's leadership role within the Congress party.
Sonia Gandhi's memoir Belonging blends her personal life story with reflections on Indian political history, addressing past controversies and highlighting Rahul Gandhi's leadership role within the Congress party.
SONIA GANDHI WAS worried that her son Rahul would talk politics at the formal launch of her memoir Belonging on November 16 in Delhi. He instead spoke about her resilience, her love and the two phases of her life: before and after the deaths of his grandmother and father. It might sound odd that political talk should be avoided when their lives have been defined by it, and when even the front rows of the audience were filled with alliance partners of the Congress. Perhaps that has been the predicament Sonia has faced over the decades, as twists of fate pushed her into the volatile world of politics.
She reminisces on the penultimate page of her memoir: “I sometimes think of how our lives might have turned out if fate had allowed Rajiv (Gandhi) to remain in his profession as an airline pilot. In my dream we’d have grown old together in the house he’d built for his mother, enjoyed our grandchildren, travelled in India and abroad, places I longed to see, to gaze at the treasures nature and humankind have created.”
The running theme of the memoir is her love story and her deeply personal world. What readers get is an endearing and moving account of her struggle to belong in an alien culture, and of the politics of the times.
She begins at a Greek restaurant in Cambridge. She was a homesick Italian student living on tinned spaghetti on toast. At the next table sat a quiet young man in a black jersey, whom she took to be from Naples, Sicily or Spain. She took an instant liking to him, but did not know then that he was Rajiv Gandhi, scion of a powerful political family from India.
Several such personal accounts follow, but the memoir performs another critical task, and its resonance will be felt for decades. She provides details and versions of events that have repeatedly been held against the Congress and the Gandhi family. This gives her children, particularly Rahul, a clean slate for their future political work, without the ghosts of the past hanging over them.
She relies on conversations with her mother-in-law, Indira Gandhi, Rajiv and senior leaders to deal with some of the most sensitive events of our times: the Emergency, Operation Blue Star, Indira’s assassination, the anti-Sikh riots, Rajiv’s assassination and the UPA era.
On Emergency, she writes that after the Allahabad High Court verdict on June 12, 1975, Indira asked Rajiv repeatedly whether she should resign and he said yes. Her other son, Sanjay, told her they wanted to finish her. She says Indira was never at ease with Emergency, and that when she decided on elections, Rajiv told her he thought it was right even if the party lost.
On Operation Blue Star, Sonia says she could see her mother-in-law’s face wet with “tears of pain and regret” as she watched the film of the aftermath. She says Indira was reluctant to order military action because it would hurt Sikh sentiments, but did so “reluctantly” because of intelligence inputs.
Since the book hit the stands, various BJP leaders have accused her of softening events, particularly Emergency and 1984, so that no blame would fall on the Gandhi family.
There are also details about backroom proceedings, such as the unspoken division of responsibilities she had with prime minister Manmohan Singh, with the government under him and the party under her. She also dismisses as false the claim by one of his former aides that she saw official files. As UPA chairperson, Congress president and head of the National Advisory Council, she describes herself as a perpetual motion machine. She lists the Right to Information, MGNREGA and the Food Security Act as the NAC’s achievements, and says she was sad to miss the vote on the Food Security Act because she was unwell.
Though she may not have been very articulate politically, her astuteness was never called into question. She played a key part in stitching together the UPA and later the INDIA bloc.
The book also painstakingly builds Rahul’s character throughout. He is a boy adored by his grandmother, and loved and disciplined by his father.
Sonia says she still waits anxiously for Rahul and Priyanka to return from rallies.
The children are present throughout, and they are protectors. On the day Rajiv was killed in May 1991, Priyanka conveyed the news to her mother. Earlier, in 1984, Rahul and Priyanka were taken out of boarding school because of kidnap threats and spent the last weeks of their grandmother’s life at home. Rahul had been told by Indira that he must not cry if anything happened to her.
Rahul dominates several pages of the book, and it becomes clear that he is leading the charge and is the inheritor of the Nehru-Gandhi legacy. In the Bharat Jodo Yatra pages, she writes that the two yatras wiped out the image of him opponents had carefully built. In her view, he came to be seen for what he is: “A man with grit and determination, a man with intellect and a clean heart.”
She recalls that Rahul kept telling her before the 2024 elections that the tide was changing: “Just wait, Ma, things will change.” When the results came on June 4, she says, she heard drums approaching from the party office next door.
The book, which its publishers claim has broken several records, has created a buzz. It humanises and softens Sonia’s image, and might get critics to look at the Congress as more than the sum of its mistakes. Perhaps that is also an argument for seeing it as a credible alternative.
The bonhomie visible at the launch—with allies and even former Punjab chief minister Amarinder Singh (now with the BJP)—sends a message that the opposition is closing ranks as the fight for 2029 approaches. Perhaps, that’s another battle Sonia wants to see unfold successfully as it did 25 years ago, but this time for Indira’s and Rajiv’s political heir.