The Republican race for the party's 2016 presidential nomination erupted into a four-candidate crossfire on Wednesday over who has the proper experience and is the most conservative, days before South Carolina voters put their stamp on the campaign.
In TV interviews and campaign events, front-runner Donald Trump threatened to sue US Senator Ted Cruz of Texas over a negative TV ad, while US Senator Marco Rubio of Florida accused Cruz of lying about his record, and former Florida Governor Jeb Bush questioned Rubio's experience to serve as president.
Amid the squabbling, South Carolina Governor Nikki Haley endorsed Rubio as the Republicans' best hope for winning the White House on November 8, a big boost to Rubio and a blow to Bush, who had lobbied hard for her to pick him.
Bush had a tough day, learning of Haley's endorsement right before a town hall meeting in Summerville, South Carolina, where four members of the audience second-guessed his campaign strategy and offered tips on how to have a greater impact in the state that holds its Republican primary on Saturday.
Much of the debate took place over the television airwaves, as Trump lobbed charges at his rivals on an MSNBC town hall, and Rubio and Cruz battled in back-to-back appearances at a CNN town hall in Greenville, South Carolina.
Trump fumed about a TV ad put out by the Cruz campaign that brought up Trump's past position in support of a woman's right to an abortion. Trump says he has evolved into a conservative and is now against abortion.
"You look at a guy like Ted Cruz, he's a nasty guy," Trump said. "He doesn't have one Republican endorsement from the Senate and he works with the Senate. Think of it. Hard to believe."
Cruz dared Trump to sue him over the campaign ad, which featured a 1999 video clip of Trump, a billionaire businessman and former reality TV star, saying he was "very pro-choice" on abortion.
Cruz said Trump sent his campaign a "cease and desist letter" demanding it drop the ad. At the CNN town hall, he said he laughed out loud when he got the letter threatening what he called a "frivolous lawsuit."
"In any defamation case, truth is a complete defense," Cruz said.
Cruz reveled in an NBC/Wall Street Journal poll that said Republicans nationally now put him ahead of Trump, 28 per cent to 26 per cent.
The latest national Reuters/Ipsos poll, however, showed Trump taking a more than 20-point lead over Cruz in the Republican race.
Trump had 40 per cent support in the poll conducted from Saturday to Wednesday, compared with 17 per cent for Cruz, 11 per cent for Rubio, 10 per cent for retired neurosurgeon Ben Carson, and 8 per cent for Bush.
Rubio, hoping to overtake Cruz for second place in South Carolina, where Trump leads in the polls, accused Cruz of spreading falsehoods with an ad attacking Rubio over his position on immigration.
Rubio backed a 2013 Senate immigration reform effort that collapsed. Cruz says Rubio would have supported "amnesty" for illegal immigrants, which his rival denies.
"If you say something that isn't true and you say it over and over and you know it's not true, it must be a lie," Rubio said.
Bush, running fourth in South Carolina and behind Rubio, questioned Rubio's level of experience after Rubio said Bush did
not have foreign policy experience. Rubio counts his time on the Senate Foreign Relations Committee as valuable experience.
"It's hard for me to be lectured to by a gifted young guy who thinks going to committee hearings means you know something about the world," Bush said in Summerville.
At the event, Bush sounded a note of frustration at frequent criticism of his campaign by TV pundits.
"The pundits have made it all—it's all decided. We don't have to go vote, I guess. It's all finished. I should stop campaigning, maybe, huh? It's all done," he said.
"No," shouted people in the crowd.
Haley's endorsement gave Rubio, 44, a valuable ally to try to sway voters in South Carolina, the third contest after Iowa and New Hampshire to pick a party nominee for the November election to succeed Democratic President Barack Obama.
"If we elect Marco Rubio, every day will be a great day in America," Haley said, with Rubio at her side at an event in Chapin, South Carolina.
Some political analysts have said Haley could be picked as the Republican vice presidential nominee.
A Bush aide said Haley called Bush to inform him of her plan to endorse Rubio.
“Disappointed” was Bush's response. “She’s a very good governor and should I win the nomination, there’ll be a role for her in the campaign,” Bush, 63, told reporters after a campaign event in Summerville. "Trust me, she's a great person."